Fabric or Steel Building: Which is right for me?

Choosing between a fabric building and a prefabricated steel building depends on your site conditions, usage, budget, and long-term plans. Both structures are engineered and durable, but each offers different strengths. Here’s how to understand the differences—and how to determine the best fit for your project.

 

1. Structural Differences

Fabric Buildings

  • Built with a galvanized steel frame covered by a tensioned fabric membrane

  • Lightweight but extremely strong

  • Naturally bright interior due to the translucent cover, excellent for remote conditions

  • Capable of being insulated but less efficient

  • Fast installation, minimal foundation requirements

Steel Buildings

  • Made from rigid-frame or arch-style steel components, completely enclosed in metal cladding

  • Heavier, more rigid, and designed for high-load, permanent applications

  • Offers full climate control when insulated

  • Usually Requires more substantial foundations and longer assembly time

2. Cost Comparison

Fabric Buildings

  • Lower upfront cost usually

  • Installation is faster → lower labour cost

  • Foundations can be lighter (blocks, piers, screw piles), and therefore less costlier

Steel Buildings

  • Higher initial investment

  • Stronger, permanent structure

  • Better long-term ROI for heavy industrial use or heated buildings

3. Installation & Foundation Requirements

Fabric Buildings

  • Quick setup (days or weeks)

  • Can be installed on:

    • Concrete blocks

    • Screw piles

    • Concrete pads or piers

    • Existing asphalt or gravel (in some cases)

  • DIY-friendly for smaller models

Steel Buildings

  • Longer assembly (weeks to months)

  • Typically require:

    • Concrete slabs

    • Grade beams

    • Piers/pile caps

  • Better suited for engineered foundations

  • More complex DIY due to weight and precision

4. Durability & Lifespan

Fabric Buildings

  • 15–25+ years on fabric, 30+ years on frames

  • Covers can be replaced without replacing the structure

  • Highly resistant to corrosion

  • Handles snow and wind well when tensioned properly

Steel Buildings

  • 40–60+ year lifespan

  • Extremely strong and rigid

  • Can support heavy equipment, cranes, mezzanines

5. Condensation & Climate Control

Fabric Buildings

  • Fabric membranes breathe slightly → lower condensation risk but still needs to be considered

  • Great for equipment storage, agriculture, or bulk materials

  • Heated options are possible but less efficient

Steel Buildings

  • Can be fully insulated and climate-controlled

  • Better for workshops, industrial use, and year-round heating

  • Requires insulation + ventilation to control condensation. At minimumum insulation for the roof.

hybrid

Hybrid Buildings

Looking for the perfect combination? We can tailor your project to feature both fabric and steel elements to fit your needs. The image on the left shows a hybrid building with a fabric main cover and sturdy steel end walls. The steel ends provide extra protection against potential vehicle contact and damage.

Ask us about this option
How to Determine the Best Choice for Your Project:

 

1. Intended Use

  • Will you heat the building?

  • Is it for people working inside, or equipment storage?

  • Do you need climate control?

2. Site Conditions

  • Soil type (weak soil may favour screw piles → fabric)

  • Available space

  • Local code requirements

  • Is the site remote? → Fabric

3. Budget & Timeline

  • Need something installed quickly or temporarily? → Fabric

  • Investing in a long-term asset? → Steel

4. Structural Requirements

  • Do you need heavy-load capacity?

  • Overhead cranes, fire-rated walls, or interior build-outs? → Steel

5. Portability

  • Need to relocate in the future? → Fabric

Fabric vs Steel Buildings - A Quick Comparison
steelvsfabric
fabric-building-8

Fabric Buildings

Choose a fabric building if you want a fast, cost-effective structure with bright natural light, low maintenance, wide clear spans, and the flexibility to relocate or expand as your needs change.

concrete pad

Steel Buildings

Choose a steel building if you need maximum durability, long-term lifespan, higher insulation options, strict engineering for snow or wind loads, and a structure that can support heavy equipment, mezzanines, cranes, or permanent commercial use.